Guide · Ingredients & Syrups

Pumpkin Spice Syrup for Cocktails and Lattes

How to make pumpkin spice syrup at home with maple syrup, brown sugar, real pumpkin puree, a cinnamon stick, and pumpkin pie spice, simmered, strained fine so no grain reaches the glass, and finished with vanilla. Keeps two weeks in the fridge.

6 min read

Pumpkin Spice Syrup for Cocktails and Lattes

The recipe

This batch makes about one cup of finished syrup, enough for roughly six drinks at the half ounce pour most fall cocktails call for. It takes about fifteen minutes at the stove and asks for nothing you cannot find on a fall grocery run.

You will need

  • 1 cup water
  • 1/4 cup maple syrup
  • 1/4 cup brown sugar
  • 3 tablespoons pumpkin puree, plain pumpkin and nothing else
  • 1 cinnamon stick
  • 1 teaspoon pumpkin pie spice
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract

Put the water, the maple syrup, the brown sugar, the pumpkin puree, the cinnamon stick, and the pumpkin pie spice in a small saucepan and whisk it together while it is still cold, because the puree folds into cold water far more willingly than into a hot pan. Set the pan over medium high heat and bring it to a boil, whisking now and then so the sugar dissolves clean and nothing catches on the bottom.

Drop the heat to medium low and let the pan simmer for about eight minutes, until the syrup lightly coats the back of a spoon. Take the pan off the heat and pull the cinnamon stick out. Pour the syrup through a fine sieve set over a jug or a bowl, pressing the pulp gently with the back of a spoon to push the liquid through, and leave the coarsest solids behind in the sieve rather than forcing them through. Stir the vanilla into the warm strained syrup, let it cool to room temperature, then pour it into a clean sealed jar or bottle and put it in the fridge.

Why the straining step matters

A lot of homemade pumpkin syrup disappoints in the glass for one plain reason: the puree never leaves. Pumpkin puree is cooked pumpkin flesh, and flesh does not dissolve in hot water, no matter how long the pan simmers. Left unstrained, those fine solids ride into the finished drink, where they read as a slight grain on the tongue and sink to the bottom of the glass in a soft sludge.

Straining fixes the texture without costing flavour. The spice, the maple, and the pumpkin taste itself all live in the liquid after eight minutes of simmering, carried there by the heat and the sugar. What stays behind in the sieve is texture, and texture is the one part of the puree a syrup never needed. Press gently as you strain. Forcing the pulp hard through the mesh pushes the coarse solids back into the syrup and undoes the whole step.

Even strained, a little fine solid gets through, and it settles while the jar sits in the fridge. That settling is normal and it is not a flaw in the batch. Shake the jar well before every pour and the settled solids fold back in, the syrup pours even, and every drink gets the same measure of pumpkin as the one before it.

Getting the body right

Syrup sweetened with maple alone pours thin, because maple syrup is mostly water by the time it has flavoured a full cup of added water. This recipe answers that in two places. The brown sugar beside the maple gives the pan something with real body to dissolve, and the full eight minute simmer lets a little of the water leave as steam, so what pours off the spoon is a syrup rather than a flavoured water.

Judge the pan by the spoon, not the clock. Dip a spoon in, lift it out, and run a finger across the back. The syrup is ready when it holds the line your finger drew for a second before it creeps back together. It will still look loose in the pan, because heat lies about thickness. The same syrup, chilled overnight, pours noticeably thicker than it did warm.

Storage and shaking

Cool the syrup fully before it goes into its jar, because a warm sealed jar sweats inside the fridge and waters the top layer down. In a clean sealed jar the batch keeps about two weeks. A bottle with a pour spout is worth using if you have one, since syrup makes a sticky ring on every shelf it touches and a spout keeps the mess in the bottle.

For keeping past two weeks, freeze the batch in an ice cube tray. Each cube is close to a tablespoon, two cubes give you the half ounce a cocktail usually wants, and a cube thaws in a few minutes in the shaker tin while you build the rest of the drink. Frozen, the syrup keeps for months with its spice intact.

Whatever the container, shake or stir it before every single pour. The fine pumpkin solids settle within hours, the top of the jar pours thinner and paler than the bottom, and unshaken syrup means the first drink of the batch and the last drink of the batch are two different drinks.

Where to use it

The syrup was built for the bar first. The Pumpkin Spice White Russian pours half an ounce of it under vodka, coffee liqueur, and cream, and it is the drink that shows the syrup at its best, because the cream gives the spice a soft landing. The Pumpkin Spice Espresso Martini takes the same half ounce against fresh espresso, where the coffee and the pumpkin spice lean on each other and both come out stronger. At breakfast the same jar is the whole point of Pumpkin Pancakes with Pumpkin Spice Syrup over on Cooking with Dade, with spoonfuls worked into the batter and more warmed for pouring over the stack.

Away from the bar, a spoonful stirred into a latte, a cold brew, or a mug of steamed milk gives you the coffee shop pumpkin drink at home, at a strength you control. It also sweetens an old fashioned in place of plain syrup when the night wants a fall edge, and a drizzle over roasted sweet potatoes or a bowl of oatmeal is a fair use of the last inch of any jar.

Common problems and fixes

Grain in the finished drink. The syrup was not strained, or the pulp was pressed hard enough to force solids through the sieve. Strain the batch again through the finest sieve you own, pressing gently this time, and shake the jar before pouring.

A layer of sludge in the jar. Normal settling, not spoilage. The fine solids that pass any sieve sink as the jar rests. Shake before every pour and the syrup goes back to even.

Syrup too thin. It left the heat too early or the maple carried the batch alone. Pour it back into a clean pan, simmer it down for a few more minutes until it coats a spoon, and chill it fully before judging it again.

Syrup too sweet. The puree can was pie filling, or the brown sugar was packed hard into the cup. Add a splash of water and a pinch of salt, warm it through, and taste again. Salt quiets sweetness faster than dilution does.

Spice that tastes raw or dusty. The spice went in old, or the simmer was too short to bloom it. Pumpkin pie spice needs its minutes in the hot pan to round out, and a jar of spice that has sat open since last fall will taste like dust no matter what the pan does. Fresh spice and the full simmer fix it.

Questions

How long does pumpkin spice syrup keep?

Sealed in a clean jar or bottle in the fridge, about two weeks. The syrup has no preservatives working for it, so if it smells sour, grows anything on the surface, or tastes off, pour it out and make a fresh batch. For longer keeping, freeze it in an ice cube tray and thaw a cube or two as a drink calls for them.

Why does pumpkin spice syrup need straining?

Pumpkin puree is a solid before it is anything else, and solids left sitting in a syrup will reach the glass as a faint grain on the tongue. A pass through a fine sieve, pressing the pulp gently and leaving the coarsest solids behind, takes the grain out while the flavour stays in the liquid.

Can I use pumpkin pie filling instead of pumpkin puree?

Plain pumpkin puree is the right can. Pie filling arrives sweetened and spiced before it ever meets your pan, so the syrup turns too sweet and the spice balance lands wherever the can decided it should. Puree is pumpkin and nothing else, which leaves the sweetness and the spice in your hands.

Why is my pumpkin spice syrup thin?

Most thin batches were sweetened with maple alone and barely simmered. Maple brings flavour more than body, so this recipe adds brown sugar beside it and simmers the pan until the syrup lightly coats the back of a spoon. Chill does the rest of the work, because cold syrup always pours thicker than warm syrup.

What drinks use pumpkin spice syrup?

Any fall drink that wants pumpkin and warm spice in one pour. On this site it sweetens the Pumpkin Spice White Russian and the Pumpkin Spice Espresso Martini, and away from the bar it turns a plain latte, a cold brew, or a mug of steamed milk into a pumpkin spice version with one spoonful.